Home >  News >  College vs. Pro: MLB The Show 25 Career Choice

College vs. Pro: MLB The Show 25 Career Choice

by Logan Apr 21,2025

*MLB The Show 25* has arrived, bringing with it an exciting new chapter of Road to the Show. This mode allows players to step into the cleats of a major league hopeful, embarking on a journey from high school to the big leagues. One of the first crucial decisions you'll face is whether to go to college or go pro. Let's dive into what each path offers in *MLB The Show 25* Road to the Show.

Should You Choose College or the Big Leagues in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show?

Choosing between college and pros in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show.

In *MLB The Show 25*, you start as a high school player with a significant decision looming. Scouts from top colleges and major league teams are eyeing your talent, but you can only choose one path. Your journey begins at the end of high school, where you and your team are in the midst of a state title run. Scouts will be present at your games, discussing your future. As you play, you'll learn about the teams interested in drafting you, and your performance in high school games and the MLB Combine will influence your draft stock and college recruitment.

After the MLB Combine, you commit to a school, and the draft follows. Even if you plan on attending college, a team will draft you. At this juncture, *MLB The Show 25* presents you with clear options. Here's what The Escapist encountered after being drafted:

  • If I Go Pro
    • Receive a signing bonus of 5 Tokens
    • Reduced chance of being fast-tracked to the Major Leagues
    • Begin pro career as an 18-year-old
  • If I Go To College
    • Receive all benefits of LSU’s official offer
    • Pursue being the #1 overall pick in a future MLB Draft
    • Begin pro career as a 21-year-old after college career is completed

The choice ultimately boils down to personal preference. If you've spent previous seasons grinding through the minor leagues, opting for college might offer a refreshing change. The allure of being the #1 overall pick and entering the pros as a more developed player can be immensely rewarding. However, if you relish the challenge of climbing from the bottom to the top, going pro right out of high school might be more appealing.

The Escapist chose to attend college, drawn by the chance to be the #1 overall pick and the promise of a unique experience. Importantly, the game fast-forwards to your third year in college during a championship run, meaning you don't spend too much time away from professional baseball. This option allows you to experience both worlds without a prolonged delay.

So, whether you should go to college or go pro in *MLB The Show 25* Road to the Show depends on what kind of journey you want to embark on. If you're looking for more tips, check out the best pitching settings for the new sports game.

*MLB The Show 25 is now in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.*