Darle's Fate in Avowed: Stop or Support in 'Fires in the Mine' Quest?

In *Avowed*, the Fires in the Mine side quest presents players with a morally nuanced decision: support Darle’s rebellion or stop him to protect the mining operation. Much like other quests in the game, both paths have their justifications within the narrative context. However, when it comes to maximizing rewards—be it XP, coin, loot, or story impact—stopping Darle proves to be the more beneficial choice.

Should You Stop or Support Darle in Avowed’s ‘Fires in the Mine’ Quest?

If your goal is to walk away with the most substantial reward package from the Fires in the Mine quest, stopping Darle is the superior option. While supporting him still grants a respectable amount of XP, the combination of XP, currency, and loot gained from thwarting his plan makes the alternative far more rewarding.

Rewards for Supporting Darle

By siding with Darle and allowing him to detonate the mine, you’ll earn 1,026 XP after speaking with Kada and Seyon. However, this decision nullifies any financial reward that would otherwise be granted, as the mining initiative is destroyed. Additionally, choosing this path damages the relationship between the Aedyrans and Thirdborn, which may affect future interactions and world state developments.

You can attempt to deflect blame by fabricating an explanation for the mine’s destruction, but the consequences remain unchanged. The mission concludes with no additional items or meaningful benefits beyond the XP awarded.

Rewards for Stopping and Killing Darle

Choosing to stop Darle results in greater overall gains. First, you’ll receive 212 XP for defeating him in combat. Then, upon debriefing with the mining officials, you’ll earn an additional 879 XP—bringing your total to 1,091 XP, which is 65 XP more than the alternative.

Beyond XP, Seynon and Kada will reward you with 900 coins as thanks for preventing the sabotage. Before leaving the mine, you can also loot Darle’s body for the following:

• Blackwood Branch (Superb Upgrade Material)
• Wild Mushroom Stew (Prepared Food)
• Beetle Pie (Prepared Food) x2

While the food items are minor conveniences, the Blackwood Branch is a valuable resource for upgrading weapons and armor, making it a particularly useful bonus. This combination of XP, gold, and high-value materials clearly outperforms what you’d gain from letting Darle succeed.

From a narrative standpoint, maintaining the alliance between the Aedyrans and Thirdborn also contributes positively to the broader storyline, especially if you're invested in shaping the game world through your choices.

Final Thoughts

Although both options offer thematic justification, stopping Darle in the Fires in the Mine quest delivers the best mix of tangible rewards and positive world impact. For players aiming to maximize their gains and progression, this is the clear-cut choice.

Now that you know the optimal decision in Fires in the Mine, consider exploring all 12 Treasure Map locations in *Avowed* to uncover exclusive gear. If you’re focused on character growth, check what the maximum level cap is so you can plan your journey toward godlike power.